1454 Main Street, Sarasota,
FL 34236
A Bit About Us

The Bar

Welcome to Brewster’s Tavern. Sarasota’s Newest Gastropub on Main Street.

Offering a wide variety of Craft Draft Beers, Signature Cocktails, Full Menu, and EVERY DirecTV Sports Package available!


$3 Domestic Drafts, Wells, Wines. $1 OFF All Craft Drafts 11am – 7pm

all our items come a la carte

The Menu

  • Chips & Salsa

    Add House Beer Cheese $3


  • Truffalo Pig Wings

    Mini Pork Shanks, Herb Roasted, fried and tossed in Our Truffalo Sauce. Topped with Micro Greens


  • Fried Street Corn

    Try Our Twist on Mexican Corn. Brushed with Chipotle Butter. Topped with Cotija, Crema, & Cilantro


  • Twisted Pub Pretzels

    Cooked to order Pub Pretzels. House Beer Cheese & Hot Mustard


  • Signature Sauces

    Mango Chili Glaze, Blue Buffalo, Firecracker, Jameson Honey, Jalapeno Ranch

  • Available Sauces

    Ranch Dressing, Bleu Cheese Dressing, Buffalo Wing Sauce, Hot Sauce, Spicy Mustard, Honey Mustard, BBQ Sauce, Sour Cream

  • Firecracker Cauliflower

    Our House Battered Cauliflower Wings, drizzled with Firecracker Sauce, Roasted Peanuts. Side of Ranch or Blue Cheese.


  • Carnita-Dilla

    Chef’s Signature Braised Carnitas, Chipotle Wrap, Custom Blend Cheese, Served with Slaw, Salsa, & Sour Cream
    (Cheese $6.99 | Chicken $9.99)


  • Goat Cheese Bombs

    Roasted Red Pepper & Jalapeno, infused Goat Cheese, Panko, Fried to golden. Ale Glaze & Red Pepper Jalapeno on top


  • Onion Rings

    Thick Cut Red Onions, Beer Battered & Fried Golden. Served with Jalapeno Ranch Dressing


  • Fry Basket

    Sweet Potato Fries $6.99 | Truffle Fries $7.99
    Load them up! $3


  • Ale Wings

    6 Wings – $7.99 | 12 Wings – $12.99 | 18 Wings-$17.99

    Try One of Our Signature Sauces
    Mango Chili Glaze
    Topped with Green Onion
    Blue Buffalo Sauce
    Topped with Blue Cheese Crumbles
    Firecracker Sauce
    Topped with Crushed Roasted Peanuts
    Truffalo Sauce
    Topped with Micro Greens
    Teriyaki Ponzu
    Topped with Sesame Seeds

    Or Try a Dry Rub!
    Lemon Pepper

  • Carnitas De Verde

    Signature Carnitas, Salsa Verde, Cotija, & Fried Onions


  • Pickled Pollo Tacos

    Signature Pickle Back Tenders, Roasted Pepper, Pickled Jalapeno Ranch, & Spicy Greens


  • Blazing Dorado Tacos

    Grilled Cajun Mahi, Kale Slaw, Peach & Mango Salsa, House Crema, & Avocado


  • Cauliflower Tacos

    Beer Batter Cauliflower, Blue Buffalo Sauce, Cotija, Scallions


  • The Brew Burger

    Custom Blend beef, Cheddar Cheese, Apple Cider Bacon on a Brioche Bun, LTO, Secret Sauce Spread


  • The Fuego Burger

    Our Signature Burger, grilled to temp. Pepper Jack Cheese, Jalapeno, Housemade Red Pepper Slaw, Ale Gaze


  • The Drunken Pig

    Chef’s Signature Braised Carnitas, Tequila Cilantro Slaw, topped with Beer Fried Pineapple, on a Brioche Bun


  • The Main Street B.L.T.

    Brew Bacon, Lettuce, Tomatoes. Toasted Sour Dough Bread. Garlic Aioli


  • Plain Jane

    Choice of Grilled or Fried Chicken. LTO, served on a Brioche Bun


  • Tavern Wrap

    Grilled Chicken, topped with Our Cheese Blend, Tossed in Your Choice of Sauce, LTO, Wrapped in a Tomato Basil Tortilla


  • Downtown Filet

    Tenderloin Cut Filet grilled to order. Pickled Onions, Parmesan, Tequila Kale, Garlic Aioli. Served on a Brioche Bun


  • The Blazing Rooster

    Cajun Marinated Chicken Breast, flash fried to order, Pickles, Garlic Ailoi, on a Brioche Bun


  • Gallo Diablo

    The Blazing Rooster souped up with Firecracker Sauce, Pepper Jack Cheese & Jalapeno Ranch


  • Fusion Fish Sandwich

    Grilled Mahi, Citrus Coleslaw, Housemade Tartar, served on a Brioche Bun


  • Pickle Back Tenders

    Scratch battered Chicken Tenders, Marinated in a Pickle Juice Blend. Spiked Jameson Honey Mustard on the side


  • House Salad

    Seasoned Kale, Tomato, Onion, & Corn. Tossed in Housemade garden Herb Vinaigrette. Topped with Cotija & Nutritional Yeast
    Add Chicken $3.99 Filet $7.99


  • Kale Caesar Salad

    Seasoned Kale, House Croutons tossed in Caesar, Topped with Parmesan, Pickled Onion, & Nutritional Yeast
    Add Chicken $3.99 Filet $7.99


  • Dessert Waffles

    Deep Fried Belgian Waffles dusted in Cinnamon, Mallo Creme, & Caramel


  • Chef’s Weekly Treat

    Ask your Bartender for Details

  • Sides

    $2.00 – Fries, Tequila Cilantro Coleslaw, Kale Slaw
    $3.00 – Street Corn, Sweet Potato Fries, Truffle Fries
    Chef’s Seasonal Treat – Ask Bartender for Details

  • SUNDAYS 11AM – 4PM

    One (1) A La Carte Brunch Entree. Endless Bloody Marys, Mimosas, Wells, Domestic Drafts, & House Wines. Also includes Soft Drinks & Juices (BRUNCH NOT AVAILABLE DURING NFL SEASON)

  • Pickle Back & Waffles

    Chef’s Pickle Back Tenders Glazed with Ale Syrup, Golden Belgian Waffles, Berry Butter


  • Tavern Hash

    Chorizo Potato Hash, Roasted Peppers, Scallions, Garnished with 2 Fried Eggs, Avacado


  • Tavern Brunch Wrap

    Eggs scrambled, Cheese Blend, your choice of Bangers or Bacon. Wrapped with peppers & potatoes in a Tomato Basil Tortilla


  • Gastro Avo Toast

    Toasted Sourdough, Fresh Avocado, Topped with Pickled Onions, Fresh Cracked Pepper, and sesame seeds


  • Wake Up Burger

    Our Signature Burger, East Egg, Lettuce, Brew Bacon, Blue Cheese, & Garlic Aioli


  • Fresh Start Tacos

    Blackened & Herb Roasted Pulled Chicken topped with Seasoned Kale, Salsa Verde, & Cotija


  • Brew Bacon

    Caramelized Apple Cider Bacon, Raw Sugar, Cayenne, Bourbon Syrup


  • A LA CARTE SIDES $1.99 Each

    Side of Bangers | Side of Bacon | 2 Eggs

please drink responsibly

The Bar


  • Bud Light

    St. Louis, MO 4.2%
  • Coors Light

    Golden, CO 4.2%
  • Miller Lite

    Milwaukee, WI 4.1%
  • Mich Ultra

    St. Louis, MO 4.2%
  • Yuengling

    Pottsville, PA 4.5%
  • Stella Artois

    Belgium 5%
  • Cigar City Jai Alai IPA

    Tampa, FL 7.5%
  • Calusa Focus IPA

    Sarasota, FL 7.5%
  • Guinness Draught

    Ireland 4.2%
  • Blue Moon Belgian Wheat

    Golden, CO 5.4%
  • Sam Adams Seasonal

    Boston, MA
  • JDub’s Passion Wheat

    Sarasota, FL 4.2%
  • Motorworks V-Twin Lager

    Bradenton, FL 4.7%
  • Budweiser

    Bud Light

    Miller Lite

    Coors Light

    Mich Ultra

    Dos XX Lager


    Corona Light


  • Amstel Light

    Stella Artois

    New Castle

    Angry Orchard


    PBR 16oz Can

    Tecate 16oz Can

    White Claw

    Becks NA

  • Homemade Sangria

    Red Wine, triple sec, lime juice, grenadine, soda water, poured over a muddled orange & cherry. Shaken, orange & cherry garnish

  • Rum-Mosa

    Malibu Coconut Rum, splash of Prosecco Champagne, topped with cranberry & oj. Rolled, orange & cherry garnish

  • Coconut H2O

    Malibu Coconut Rum, coconut water, splash of pineapple juice. Shaken, lemon & cherry garnish

  • The Carlton

    Beefeater Gin, splash of St. Germain, splash of Chambord, topped with tonic. Shaken, lime garnish

  • Northern Lights

    Three Olives Cucumber Vodka, agave nectar, splash of lemonade, topped with soda water. Shaken, Midori Melon Liqueur floater & cucumber garnish

  • The Shelby Sidecar

    Bulleit Bourbon, fresh lemon squeeze, splash of cointreau, topped with soda water. Shaken, lemon garnish

  • Champagne Mule

    Tito’s Handmade Vodka, Prosecco Champagne, topped with ginger beer, lemon garnish

  • The Green Mule

    Jameson Irish Whiskey, peach schnapps, sour, oj, & ginger beer, lime garnish

  • Sutter Home

  • Sutter Home

    Pinot Grigio
  • Kendall Jackson

  • Estancia

    Pinot Grigio
  • Kim Crawford

    Sauvignon Blanc
  • Prosecco

  • Sutter Home

  • Sutter Home

    Cabernet Sauvignon
  • Blackstone

  • Coppola

    Cabernet Sauvignon
  • Meiomi

    Pinot Noir