1454 Main Street, Sarasota,
FL 34236
A Bit About Us

The Bar

Welcome to Brewster’s Tavern. Sarasota’s Newest Pub & Grill on Main Street.

Offering a wide variety of Craft Draft Beers, Signature Cocktails, Full Menu, and EVERY DirecTV Sports Package available!


11am – 7pm $3 Domestic Drafts, Wells, Wines. $1 OFF All Craft Drafts

all our items come a la carte

The Menu

  • Chips & Salsa

    Add Queso $3 Add a Side of Homemade Chili $0.75


  • Cup of Homemade Chili

    Try Our Homemade Chili. Topped with Shredded Cheddar, Red Onion, & Sour Cream


  • Fried Street Corn

    Try Our Twist on Mexican Corn. Deep Fried & Topped with Our Street Goodness


  • Twisted Pub Pretzels

    Cooked to order Pub Pretzels. House Beer Cheese & Ground Mustard


  • Dessert Waffles

    Deep Fried Belgian Waffles dusted in Cinnamon, Mallo Creme, & Caramel


  • Signature Sauces

    Mango Chili Glaze, Blue Buffalo, Firecracker, Jameson Honey, Jalapeno Ranch

  • Available Sauces

    Ranch Dressing, Bleu Cheese Dressing, Buffalo Wing Sauce, Hot Sauce, Spicy Mustard, Honey Mustard, BBQ Sauce, Sour Cream

  • Pickle Back Tenders

    Scratch Battered Tenders. Marinated in a Pickle Juice Blend, Served with our Spiked Jameson Honey Mustard


  • Carnita-Dilla

    Chef’s Signature Braised Carnitas, Chipotle Wrap, Custom Blend Cheese, Served with Lettuce, Tomato, & Sour Cream
    (Cheese $6.99 | Chicken $9.99)


  • Potato Basket

    Fries $5.99 | Sweet Potato Fries $6.99 | Truffle Fries $7.99
    Load them Up! $3 Add Chili $1


  • Game Changer Nachos

    House Chili, Black Bean Salsa, Beer Cheese, Jalapeno, Crema.  Add Chicken or Carnitas $2.99


  • Sides

    Fries $2 | Coleslaw $2 | Kale Slaw $2 | Street Corn $3 | Sweet Potato Fries $3 | Truffle Fries $3

  • Ale Wings

    Our Signature, Local Brewed
    Mango Chili Glazed Wings

    6 Wings – $7.99
    12 Wings – $12.99
    18 Wings – $17.99

    Try One of Our Other Signature Sauces
    Blue Buffalo Sauce
    Topped with Blue Cheese Crumbles
    Firecracker Sauce
    Topped with Crushed Roasted Peanuts


  • Firecracker Cauliflower Wings

    Our House Battered Cauliflower Wings, Drizzled with Firecracker Sauce, garnished with Roasted Peanuts. Served with a Side of Blue Buffalo Sauce


  • Truffalo Pig Wings

    Mini Pork Shanks, Herb Roasted, fried and tossed in Our Truffalo Sauce


  • Ponzu Maple Duck Wings

    Crispy Duck Drums, flash fried to order. Teriyaki Ponzu. Sesame Seed


  • The Drunken Pig

    Chef’s Signature Braised Carnitas, Tequila Cilantro Slaw, topped with a Beer Fried Pineapple Ring


  • The Blazing Rooster

    House Cajun Marinated Chicken Breast, flash fried to order in Our Seasoned Flour, topped with Pickles & Dressed with Garlic Ailoi


  • The Brew Burger

    Custom Blend Beef, topped with Munster & Cheddar Cheeses, LTO. Served on a Brioche Bun with Our Secret Sauce Spread


  • Sides

    Fries $2 | Coleslaw $2 | Kale Slaw $2 | Street Corn $3 | Sweet Potato Fries $3 | Truffle Fries $3

  • Main Street B.L.T.

    House Brew Bacon, Bib Lettuce, Heirloom Tomatoes. All on Toasted Wheat Berry Bread


  • Gallo Diablo

    Blazing Roosters Spicy Sibling! Souped up with Firecracker Sauce, Pepper Jack Cheese & Jalapeno Ranch


  • Tavern Wrap

    Grilled Chicken, topped with Our Cheese Blend, Tossed in Your Choice of Sauce, LTO. Wrapped in a Tomato Basil Tortilla


  • Caprese Wrap

    Heirloom tomatoesd. fresh Mozzarella topped with Basil & Arugala. Drizzled with Balsamic Glaze & Wrapped in a Tomato Basil Tortilla. Add Chicken $3


  • Blazing Dorado Tacos

    Grilled Cajun Mahi, Kale Slaw, Peach & Mango Salsa, House Crema, & Avocado


  • Carnitas De Verde

    Signature Carnitas, Citrus Pig Sauce, Salsa Verde. Shaved Radish


  • Pickled Pollo Tacos

    Signature Pickle Back Tenders, Roasted Pepper Salsa, Pickled Jalapeno Ranch, & Spicy Greens



    One (1) A La Carte Brunch Entree. Endless Bloody Marys, Mimosas, Wells, Domestic Drafts, & House Wines. Also includes Soft Drinks & Juices

  • Pickle Back & Waffles

    Chef’s Pickle Back Tenders Glazed with Ale Syrup, Golden Belgian Waffles, Berry Butter


  • Tavern Hash

    Chorizo Potato Hash, Roasted Peppers, Scallions, Garnished with 2 Fried Eggs, Avacado


  • Tavern Brunch Wrap

    Eggs scrambled, Cheese Blend, your choice of Bangers or Bacon. Wrapped with peppers & potatoes in a Tomato Basil Tortilla


  • The Hangover

    Our Twist on a Traditional. 3 Eggs cooked to desire, Bangers, Wheat Berry Bread, House Almond Butter, Blackberry Gastrique


  • Wake Up Burger

    Our Signature Burger, fried egg bib, Brew Baccon, Blue Cheese


  • Brew Bacon

    Caramelized Apple Cider Bacon, Raw Sugar, Cayenne, Bourbon Syrup


  • A LA CARTE SIDES $1.99 Each

    Side of Bangers | Side of Bacon | 2 Eggs | Bread

please drink responsibly

The Bar


  • Bud Light

    St. Louis, MO 4.2%
  • Coors Light

    Golden, CO 4.2%
  • Miller Lite

    Milwaukee, WI 4.1%
  • Mich Ultra

    St. Louis, MO 4.2%
  • Yuengling

    Pottsville, PA 4.5%
  • Stella Artois

    Belgium 5%
  • Cigar City Jai Alai IPA

    Tampa, FL 7.5%
  • Calusa Focus IPA

    Sarasota, FL 7.5%
  • Guinness Draught

    Ireland 4.2%
  • Blue Moon Belgian Wheat

    Golden, CO 5.4%
  • Sam Adams Seasonal

    Boston, MA
  • JDub’s Passion Wheat

    Sarasota, FL 4.2%
  • Motorworks V-Twin Lager

    Bradenton, FL 4.7%
  • Budweiser

    Bud Light

    Miller Lite

    Coors Light

    Mich Ultra

    Dos XX Lager


    Corona Light


  • Amstel Light

    Stella Artois

    New Castle

    Angry Orchard


    PBR 16oz Can

    Tecate 16oz Can

    White Claw

    Becks NA

  • Homemade Sangria

    Red Wine, triple sec, lime juice, grenadine, soda water, poured over a muddled orange & cherry. Shaken, orange & cherry garnish

  • Rum-Mosa

    Malibu Coconut Rum, splash of Prosecco Champagne, topped with cranberry & oj. Rolled, orange & cherry garnish

  • Coconut H2O

    Malibu Coconut Rum, coconut water, splash of pineapple juice. Shaken, lemon & cherry garnish

  • The Carlton

    Beefeater Gin, splash of St. Germain, splash of Chambord, topped with tonic. Shaken, lime garnish

  • Northern Lights

    Three Olives Cucumber Vodka, agave nectar, splash of lemonade, topped with soda water. Shaken, Midori Melon Liqueur floater & cucumber garnish

  • The Shelby Sidecar

    Bulleit Bourbon, fresh lemon squeeze, splash of cointreau, topped with soda water. Shaken, lemon garnish

  • Champagne Mule

    Tito’s Handmade Vodka, Prosecco Champagne, topped with ginger beer, lemon garnish

  • The Green Mule

    Jameson Irish Whiskey, peach schnapps, sour, oj, & ginger beer, lime garnish

  • Sutter Home

  • Sutter Home

    Pinot Grigio
  • Kendall Jackson

  • Estancia

    Pinot Grigio
  • Kim Crawford

    Sauvignon Blanc
  • Prosecco

  • Sutter Home

  • Sutter Home

    Cabernet Sauvignon
  • Blackstone

  • Coppola

    Cabernet Sauvignon
  • Meiomi

    Pinot Noir